I recently found a couple of pair of red boots at some local shoe stores. I was wondering which (if either) of these boots would be acceptable for a RotJ Royal Guard. I realize that the straps on the sides of them would need to be removed, which is not a problem, but I'm more concerned with the lack of a heel (since the CRL says "conservative heels"), and especially the shape of the toe. One of the pair (the one with more straps) has a somewhat pointed toe, but nowhere near as pointed at the one on the CRL picture. The other is more rounded, so I'm fairly certain it wouldn't be acceptable.
First pair:

(side)

(toe)
Second pair:

(side)

(toe)
Any suggestions on them?